Showing posts with label String Theory. Show all posts
Showing posts with label String Theory. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 26, 2010

Towards a more and more complete theory..an endless journey it seems!

The hunt for a complete fundamental theory of Physics is not new, it was one of Einstein's unfulfilled dream or may be many Great minds also dreamed of it earlier. Of course it sounds so amazing that just one theory could possibly explain everything around you, but sometimes I feel if this expectation or dream is just a wish or is there any physical necessity. I mean why can't we describe two different observed phenomena using two different theories. Yes we can, but there is no guarantee that these two observed phenomena always happen separately. There may be some situations where both these phenomena are happening simultaneously (in a non-independent way because the two different systems may interact with each other) and we have no clue which theory we should use to describe them. Hence we always wish if we had a theory which can explain everything using one master equation, say. But the question is how far have we been in this really long journey of four or five decades. String theorists are doing a great job of course in developing such an elegant theory which can describe all the four fundamental forces(gravity, electromagnetic, strong and weak nuclear force) in the Universe together. There is no other theory where we can talk about all four forces. In particle physics we can talk about the later three using gauge theories, but gravity is a real bitch in such theories which (if we include) make everything meaningless. Particle physicists that's why live with these three forces only which serve their purposes also because within the region of their interests gravity is negligible. So in particle physics, a complete theory means a theory which can describe these three forces together, the so called Grand Unified Theories (GUT). There have been tremendous works in the last three and half decades on these theories. They look beautiful of course since they have strong predictivities. You write your GUT theory at very high energy and see what it predicts at low energy accessible to experimental detection. There are many models based on different gauge groups which can give rise to standard model of particle physics at low energy and also predict most of the experimental results so far. The best thing is that you start with a theory where there is only one force, only one type of particles at very high energy, and as a output you get a theory with three different forces and many different particles at low energy. But still lots of works need to be done to have a complete theory. Although the achievements in both string theory and such GUT models are tremendous so far, I am still confused whether the real goal of having such a fundamental theory is achieved (even partially) or not. Like GUT people do not talk about gravity, string theories also do not uniquely predict the observed phenomena at low energy. Recently there have been lots of enthusiasm in arriving at a GUT model starting with string theory. But to make the theory internally consistent the GUT models or any particle physics model people arrive at from string theory constructions contain many more particles than a minimal particle physics model. Thus predictivity is lost if we consider such non-minimal models. Hope people will continue such works with more and more enthusiasm and soon we will see some success in this direction.

Thursday, October 22, 2009

String Theory Video Lecture Part 5

Yesterday we had the video screening of String Theory Lecture part 5 by Prof Shiraz Minwalla. It was longer than the previous ones as well as harder to follow. He was doing Path Integrals and Conformal Field Theory most of the time, both of which I have not learned yet in a systematic way. He is referring to the chapter on CFT in Polchincki's book. I really need to go through it before attending the next video. It is not possible to sleep also during the video lecture since not more than five people come for it...:P Hence there is no other way than listening carefully to what Prof Minwalla says.

Thursday, October 15, 2009

String Theory Video Lecture Part 4

Yesterday we had the 4th weekly session of watching the string theory video lecture by Prof Shiraz Minwalla. Unfortunately the seminar room was occupied by some people and we had to move to an another room where I could not not configure my laptop with the projector and after trying for more than half an hour we decided to watch the video in the laptop only. In this part of his lecture he talked about tachyonic states in bosonic string theory and showed how 26 space-time dimensions appear naturally for the consistency of the theory. But the ground state of the theory still remains tachyonic. The first excited becomes massless for D=26. Since the 1st excited state behaves like a vector which has D-2 components and hence transform under SO(D-2) it can not be massive which transform under SO(D-1). I was wondering if we fix N=1 (1st excited state) in the the relation $$ m^2 = \frac{2}{\alpha}[ 2N-(D-2)/12] $$ and requiring this state to be massless, arrive at D=26 how would the same value of D would make the second excited state massless. Then Prof Ramadevi cleared my doubt saying that the higher excited states are Higher dimensional representation of SO(D-2) and hence need not be massless. Then he talked about $$ N= \tilde{N} = 1 $$ where the tilde means the right moving ( in case of closed string we have both left and right moving fourier modes). This corresponds to $ 24 \times 24 $ representation of SO(24) which will give rise to a massless symmetric tensor field $G_{\mu \nu}$, a massless antisymmetric tensor field $B_{\mu \nu}$ and a scalar field $ \Phi$ called the dilaton. Thus gravity comes out automatically in closed string theory. After that he gave a brief introduction to path integrals which he will probably use in his next lecture.

Wednesday, October 7, 2009

Video Lecture Part 2 and 3

Today we had the video screening of Prof Shiraz Minwalla's String Theory Lecture Part 3 in the Physics Department. Naturally the number of people coming for the lectures has decreased a lot compared to the lecture part 1. In part 2 he talked about Weyl transformations $$ {g}_{\alpha \beta} \rightarrow e^{\phi} g_{\alpha \beta} $$ as well as reparameterization invariance and how we can use them to remove one degree of freedom from the world-sheet metric and write it as $ g_{\alpha \beta} = \eta_{\alpha \beta} $ where $ \eta $ is the Minkowski metric. Then he showed how to write the action in light-cone world sheet coordinates. Then he used the constraints as well as reparameterization invariance in the light-cone world sheet coordinates to remove two degrees of freedom which results in D-2 modes of oscillations.

Today's lecture (part 3) was a bit more technical : how to quantize the action. He started with the action
$ -\frac{1}{4 \pi \alpha} \int \surd{-g} g^{\alpha \beta} \partial_{\alpha} X^{\mu} \partial_{\beta} X_{\mu} $
and went ahead to quantize it. He did not follow the conventional approach which most of the string theory books follow: find the classical canonical momenta and quantize it by giving operator meaning to the various involved quantities. He used symplectic structure approach in which he wrote the action in terms of two-forms. That part was really confusing since he was writing and erasing so many things on the black board. He mentioned that this symplectic structure approach will be very useful while doing compactifications. He is basically strictly following the string theory book by Luest and Theisen, may be looking at that book will help to understand the things he did today in a better way.

Tuesday, September 22, 2009

Video Screening of Prof Shiraz Minwalla's Lectures Part 1

Finally the day has come when the enthu people could find some common free time to sit together and watch the STRING THEORY lecture part 1 by Prof Shiraz Minwalla. This was not a new lecture video by the way, it was just taken from his TIFR webpage http://theory.tifr.res.in/~minwalla/ . Although these videos are accessible to all, Prof Ramadevi wanted us to sit together and watch such that if there is any doubt, students can ask her. It was however very difficult in the past to find a common free slot out of the tight semester schedule in IIT Bombay. But yesterday people agreed to come for it although it was a national holiday on the occasion of Eid. The first lecture was very elementary, he started with a little motivation for doing strings and then went on to discuss relativistic point particle action, the reparameterization invariance (under one to one mapping between 2 parameter space), use of lagrange multipliers in the action etc. He also made a gauge symmetry interpretation of the reparameterization invariance. I just had a small doubt if we can have a lie algebra kind of interpretation of this gauge symmetry like we have in our standard model of particle physics. Prof Ramadevi commented that this reparameterization is something more general (like a general coordinate transformation) and hence need no be specific to lie algebra. From non-academic point of view also it was enjoyable, you can guess the reason if you are aware of Prof Minwalla's body language..:P. We are planning the screening of his second lecture next week. Hope to see more people there than yesterday.
Share/Bookmark

Saturday, August 15, 2009

N=8 SUGRA versus String Theory...

I was attending SERC(Science and Engineering Research Council) THEP (Theoretical High Energy Physics) Main school in IIT Guwahati from 2nd -21st March 2009. It was during a string theory tutorial when I asked this question to the tutor Nemani Suryanarayana (IMSc, Chennai). My doubt was like we remove the quadratic divergences in scalar field (Higgs) theory by introducing supersymmetry, is the same technique can prove useful in removing or controlling the divergences in the S-matrix theory of gravitation. Since getting a renormalizable (finite) theory of gravity is one of the main motivation to do string theory, I was wondering if that could be done with usual quantum field theory with supersymmetry. Prof Nemani told me that N=8 Supergravity (local supersymmetry) in four dimension may give rise to a finite theory of gravity, but nobody has proved it beyond two loops so far. Today however I have seen a paper which was put in ArXiv sometime in May(http://arxiv.org/abs/0905.2326) which discusses this issue upto four loop calculation. Although this is a good improvement over earlier results yet someone has to prove it for the most general order. Then only a finite quantum theory of gravity with N=8 local supersymmetry will be possible. Its difficult for me to comment on string theory since I hardly know much about it. Even if N=8 SUGRA comes out as a finite theory of gravity in four dimension that won't rule out or do any harm to string theory. They are not mutually exclusive, rather one converges to another asymptotically. It is also to be noted that N=8 SUSY is unrealistic, our world has N=1 SUSY (if any) and N=1 SUSY is not enough to remove the divergences which appear in quantizing gravity. Thus although a finite N=8 SUGRA in four dimensions will be a good news yet that's not the end of story.